It’s been a tough weekend for Ulster supporters as Leinster and Munster once again perform at the highest level in the European Champions Cup.
Why can our cousins do it while we struggle? Having looked at the Ulster representation in the Six Nations squads over the last few weeks we thought we’d start our analysis by looking at the Ulster representation in the Ulster squad! 😯
Recap of Irish representation
So the Ulster representation in the Ireland squad’s hasn’t been great and in general it hasn’t been great over the last seven years.
Why seven years? Well it was in January 2010 that Shane Logan stated his plan for World Domination, with Phase 1 being Ulster becoming the best team in Ireland!
This past European Championship weekend shows just how far we are off that goal, and it’s obvious by our representation in the National sides that we are far from pulling our weight.
You would expect a province to have between 25% and 30% representation in the Ireland squads and Ulster are well short of those numbers in the three main representative sides. Note that the above percentages are based on actual time played during the Six Nations.
Ulster Representation in Ulster Squads
As we started gathering up the data on Ulster player performances throughout the season we also had a look at which players had been through the Ulster production system from school age to the senior side.
To date Les Kiss has used 48 players in his senior squads this season. The details are shown below:
Player
Squads
Starts
Minutes Played
Origin
Sean
Reidy
22
22
1562
N.Zealand
Charles
Piutau
19
19
1467
N.Zealand
Ruan
Pienaar
19
19
1356
S.Africa
Clive
Ross
23
23
1135
Munster
Luke
Marshall
17
17
1099
Ulster
Paddy
Jackson
14
14
1058
Ulster
Franco
Van der Merwe
19
19
1044
S.Africa
Iain
Henderson
13
13
940
Ulster
Rob
Herring
19
19
923
S.Africa
Louis
Ludik
14
14
909
S.Africa
Chris
Henry
13
13
905
Ulster
Andrew
Warwick
23
23
889
Ulster
Stuart
Olding
11
11
848
Ulster
Kieran
Treadwell
17
17
831
England
Tommy
Bowe
15
14
809
Ulster
Stuart
McCloskey
13
13
795
Ulster
Craig
Gilroy
13
13
782
Ulster
Rory
Best
11
11
761
Ulster
Pete
Browne
17
17
739
England
Robbie
Diack
14
14
735
S.Africa
Jacob
Stockdale
16
14
725
Ulster
Rodney
Ah You
14
14
650
N.Zealand
Alan
O’Connor
10
10
642
Leinster
Jared
Payne
9
9
635
N.Zealand
Darren
Cave
14
14
606
Ulster
Callum
Black
17
17
593
USA
Roger
Wilson
12
12
559
Ulster
Paul
Marshall
22
18
529
Ulster
Wiehahn
Herbst
12
12
524
S.Africa
Andrew
Trimble
7
7
517
Ulster
Kyle
McCall
10
10
488
Ulster
Ross
Kane
11
11
344
Ulster
Robert
Lyttle
8
6
341
Ulster
Peter
Nelson
5
5
299
Ulster
John
Andrew
17
13
296
Ulster
Brett
Heron
11
7
287
S.Africa
Marcell
Coetzee
4
4
236
S.Africa
Ricky
Lutton
5
5
214
Ulster
David
Shanahan
5
4
198
Leinster
Jonny
Simpson
4
4
126
Ulster
Dan
Tuohy
2
2
121
England
Sam
Windsor
2
2
84
Australia
Conor
Joyce
2
2
49
England
Aaron
Cairns
1
1
16
Ulster
Jack
Owens
1
1
13
Ulster
Angus
Lloyd
2
1
12
Leinster
David
Busby
2
2
12
Ulster
Johnny
Murphy
1
0
0
Ulster
A quick count shows 26 of those 48 players (54%) have been through the Ulster programme from school age. However, when we look at time on the pitch this season that figure drops to 48.7% in terms of minutes played.
Now this isn’t some BREXIT type rant to get the foreigners out. All those players are welcome inclusions to team Ulster and many have become firmly embedded in the culture and community of the province but what it does show is how comparitively limited the pathway is to the senior squad for our own youngsters.
I suppose the obvious answer would be that we just don’t have the talent, but I’m somewhat loath to accept this. However, we do need to look at our forwards.
In the backs, if you ran through your first choice picks, I’d guess that at least 70% would be Ulster developed with only Charles Piutau, Ruan Pienaar and Jared Payne being certain starters, well for this season at least.
When you look at the forwards the Ulster representation could be anything between 15% and 40% with Rory Best and Iain Henderson the only Ulster boys guaranteed a spot in the 13 squad places. Chris Henryand Kyle McCall would get in there as well, in my opinion, but they are no way guaranteed!
Whatever way you cut it though we are struggling to develop our local forwards – the keystone of any team! We’ve never had physically big players, so are we just playing the wrong way?
What do Ulster need to do
In my opinion it’s fairly straight forward. We need to develop a faster paced off loading forwards game relying on skill rather than bulk. The amount of time and money that we waste trying to bulk our players up to unrealistic proportions would be far better spent out of the gym and on the pitch developing the necessary skill sets.
If they could get the right balance between bulk and skills then it could trickle down through the club and school system and start the necessary production line of local talent.
Easy to say, but would the appetite be there for a short term drop in competitiveness? Marcell Coetzee could be the sort of player to start this transition, and in his short period of availability he seemed able to invigorate a faster game but will we have him around for long enough?
Will it happen? I don’t know. At the minute Ulster seem too happy to try and buy success rather than develop it.
Leinster is nearest comparable province to Ulster both in terms of their schools system and in terms of ‘foreign’ players in their squad, the major difference for me is in the game plan and mindset of their players which is to play with a lack of fear. Ulster players by contrast appear to be inhibited by game plans, the exception being the likes of Payne, Pititau and Coetzee. Release their inner chimp and allow the homegrown Ulster players to play their natural game and not some computer programmed numbers rugby game devised by coaches.
Corrections, comments or questions?